SHOP THE FAIR (Crafts, Gifts, Greenery, Chili, Pies)
Shop Now your Holiday Greenery, Handmade Crafts, Pies, Home Baked Goods and Chili, and once in a life time, Piece of First Church Offerings… Scarves, Ties, and Tower Notecards
Pies
Pies
Breezy Hill Orchard makes its pies in the Hudson Valley without preservatives and with the best local ingredients including Cabot Creamery butter, Breezy Hill’s own Eco-Certified apples, and fruits from neighboring farms.
Orders accepted until December 21.
Pick up your order from the Church on Wednesday, December 24th, just in time for your holiday meals!
APPLE: Grandma has nothing on this American classic pie $34
BLUEBERRY: Luscious blueberries baked in a flaky pie crust $35
CHERRY: Plump cherries baked in a flaky pie crust $39
CRANBERRY WALNUT: The best minced pie you will ever enjoy $34
PEACH RASPBERRY: Handmade with local fruit $37
PECAN: A sweet Southern specialty baked to perfection $38
CHOCOLATE BOURBON PECAN: A divine twist on the classic $33
PUMPKIN: The ideal mix of delectable spices $33
Please pick up your pie order on Wednesday, December 24, 2025, at:
The First Presbyterian Church in the City of New York
12 West 12th Street (Between 5th and 6th)
New York, NY 10011
PIE PICK-UP will be before and after the 4 pm service on Wednesday, December 24, from 12:00 pm – 5:00 pm.
Pies not picked up by the end of the Christmas Eve Family Service will be donated.
All pies come packed in a hard shell casing, perfect for transporting home.
Questions? Contact Chandra @646-250-6452 or Sarah @ 917-275-3743.